The Baby-Sitters Club Christian Review
In the middle of the whirlwind that is modern TV, every so often, a show comes along that feels like a breath of fresh air. Not just because it’s fun, sweet, and makes us laugh, but because it offers a little more—something with a pulse. That’s how I’d describe Netflix’s adaptation of The Baby-Sitters Club. You might know it from the books, or maybe you’ve heard whispers from the 90s kids who grew up with these stories. But this reboot isn’t just about bringing nostalgia to life; it’s about creating something new while holding on to the core of what made the original so beloved. And for a Christian viewer, this show, with all its warmth and optimism, gives you a lot to chew on, even if you weren’t expecting it.
Community and Friendship: A Biblical Reflection
At the heart of The Baby-Sitters Club is the idea of friendship. Not the shallow, surface-level kind, but the kind that weaves people together, making them stronger. As Christians, this idea resonates deeply. We are called to love one another, to bear each other’s burdens, and to build each other up (Galatians 6:2, 1 Thessalonians 5:11). The girls in this show do exactly that. Whether they’re supporting one another through tough times at home, lending a hand with schoolwork, or just being there to listen, they model what true friendship looks like.
These moments are subtle, but that’s what makes them real. There’s no preaching about community—it’s just there, like the air they breathe. And while the world today often pushes for self-reliance, The Baby-Sitters Club leans into the beauty of relationships, teamwork, and reliance on each other. In a way, the show reflects the Church’s call for us to be a body, where everyone’s gifts are different, but all are important (1 Corinthians 12:12-27).
Modern Issues, Timeless Values
It’s impossible to miss how this adaptation brings the 1980s and ’90s storylines into the 2020s. The show introduces modern challenges—blended families, health issues, and even identity. You see the girls grappling with these topics not in a flashy or over-dramatized way, but with sincerity and curiosity. For instance, when Kristy’s mom gets remarried, it’s not just a subplot. It’s a real-life challenge many kids face, and the show handles it with grace and thoughtfulness.
From a Christian perspective, what stands out is how these themes are treated. The show doesn’t give easy answers, but it does show characters walking through difficult situations with love and respect. In some ways, it mirrors how Christians are called to handle tough, modern issues—not with judgment, but with compassion and understanding (James 1:19). And that’s one of the show’s strengths—it doesn’t gloss over the complexities of life, but it doesn’t abandon its hopeful tone either.
Watching with Family: A Thoughtful Approach
One of the things that sets The Baby-Sitters Club apart is that it’s genuinely enjoyable for all ages. It’s rare to find a show you can confidently recommend to your younger siblings, your kids, and maybe even your parents without feeling like it’s oversimplifying or talking down to anyone. There’s a certain magic in that. It feels like an old-school family show in the best way, but with just enough humor and modernity to keep it fresh.
That said, there are a few moments where the show dips into what some would call “woke” territory. You might see subtle hints of social commentary, cultural references, or moments where certain topics are addressed in a way that feels tailored to today’s audience. For some Christian families, this might raise a few eyebrows. But honestly, nothing feels forced or out of place. It’s more of a gentle nudge to be mindful of how the world has changed and is continuing to change.
For families watching together, this can actually be a good thing. It opens up space for conversations about those shifts and how they align (or don’t) with Christian beliefs. If anything, it’s a teaching moment—a chance to sit down with your kids or siblings and talk through these ideas in light of your faith. And if you’re guiding younger viewers, that’s an opportunity to reinforce values, grounded in Scripture, while still appreciating what the show has to offer.
Role Models Worth Emulating
It’s hard not to fall in love with the cast of The Baby-Sitters Club. The five young leads breathe life into their characters, each bringing something unique to the table. Watching them is like watching your own younger sisters or friends navigate their awkward middle-school years—sometimes fumbling, sometimes shining, but always real. They’re idealistic, a bit messy, deeply caring, and, at times, even a little annoying (in a lovable way).
What strikes me as especially meaningful from a Christian viewpoint is the responsibility these girls take on. Here we have a group of middle-schoolers running a business, helping other kids, and still managing to do their homework. That sense of duty and care for others feels like an echo of biblical principles. The show celebrates these young girls as they figure out how to balance it all—work, friendship, and family—reminding us that even in the small things, we’re called to be faithful (Luke 16:10).
It’s not just the big gestures that matter. It’s the everyday kindness, the small acts of service, and the way the girls constantly step up for one another. In many ways, they model what it means to be a servant leader, someone who leads by example through humility and care for others. For Christian viewers, that’s an inspiring takeaway.
A Note on Optimism
In a world where we’re constantly bombarded with news and entertainment that can feel heavy or cynical, The Baby-Sitters Club is a breath of fresh air. It doesn’t shy away from real problems, but it refuses to let those problems overshadow the story. Instead, it leans into hope. There’s something almost old-fashioned about that, but it’s also incredibly refreshing.
This optimism isn’t cheesy or forced. It’s rooted in the belief that, no matter what challenges we face, there’s always room for growth, love, and joy. In a lot of ways, this reflects the Christian hope we’re called to live by—knowing that while the world is full of trials, we have a greater hope in Christ (Romans 5:3-5).
Final Thoughts: A Show to Watch, Reflect On, and Enjoy
Ultimately, The Baby-Sitters Club is more than just a kids’ show. It’s a reflection of the power of community, the importance of friendship, and the beauty of responsibility and care. For Christian families, it’s a rare gem in modern entertainment—wholesome, thoughtful, and full of moments that align with biblical values.
There might be moments where it touches on modern issues that feel a little different, but those are opportunities for meaningful discussion. At its core, the show is about love, kindness, and hope—themes that resonate deeply with the Christian worldview.
So, if you’re looking for something to watch that’s both entertaining and uplifting, The Baby-Sitters Club is a great choice. It’s sweet, funny, and hopeful in all the right ways—and in a world that often feels too heavy, that’s exactly what we need.
Rating: 9/10
