Call Me Kat Christian Review
Call Me Kat is like that friend who tries just a little too hard to make you laugh. She’s bubbly, she’s quirky, and she’s eager to be liked—but despite her best efforts, she struggles to connect on a deeper level. Based on the British sitcom Miranda, the show stars Mayim Bialik as Kat, a single woman in her late 30s running a cat café while navigating life, relationships, and the expectations society heaps on women her age.
On paper, it sounds like the kind of cozy sitcom that could brighten up a quiet evening. And in some moments, it does. Kat’s cheerful determination to live life on her terms is admirable, and her interactions with her feline friends are charming in their simplicity. But beyond its surface, the show stumbles in ways that are hard to ignore.
Gimmicks Galore: A Double-Edged Sword
From the very first episode, Call Me Kat makes it clear that it doesn’t want to be like other sitcoms. The show breaks the fourth wall constantly, with Kat speaking directly to the audience to share her thoughts and feelings. It’s a nod to the storytelling style of shows like Fleabag, but here, the execution feels less like an innovative narrative device and more like a crutch.
The problem isn’t just that these asides become predictable; it’s that they often interrupt the flow of the story. Instead of pulling the audience closer to Kat, they serve as a reminder that we’re watching a constructed performance. The show also ends each episode with a strange curtain call, where the cast waves at the audience as if they’ve just wrapped up a stage play. It’s a cute idea in theory but feels awkward in practice, like the writers weren’t sure how else to sign off.
As Christians, it’s worth considering what these gimmicks are trying to achieve. Are they meant to make us feel more connected to Kat? To remind us of the value of authenticity? While there’s merit in both goals, the show’s reliance on these tricks often undermines the sincerity it’s aiming for.
Kat’s Journey: A Lesson in Contentment
At the heart of Call Me Kat is a story about a woman refusing to conform. Kat isn’t married, she doesn’t have kids, and she’s not climbing the corporate ladder—and she’s fine with that. Or at least, she’s trying to be. The show often highlights the pressure society places on women to fit a certain mold, and Kat’s defiance of those expectations is refreshing.
There’s something deeply relatable about Kat’s quest for happiness on her own terms. In a world that often equates success with having it all—a career, a family, a picture-perfect Instagram feed—Kat’s willingness to embrace her imperfections is a quiet act of rebellion. From a Christian perspective, her journey is a reminder of the importance of finding contentment in our own unique paths. Philippians 4:11 comes to mind: “I have learned to be content whatever the circumstances.”
But for all its potential, the show rarely delves into the deeper questions that Kat’s life raises. Instead, it often retreats into slapstick humor and shallow storytelling. It’s frustrating because you can see the makings of a meaningful narrative, but the show never quite gets there.
Laughter with a Side of Nostalgia
Sitcoms thrive on humor, and Call Me Kat certainly tries its best to be funny. Unfortunately, many of the jokes feel dated, as if they were pulled from a script written decades ago. The slapstick moments, while occasionally amusing, often feel forced, and the dialogue struggles to find a rhythm.
It’s worth noting that the show’s humor is clean and inoffensive, which might appeal to Christian audiences tired of comedies that rely on crude jokes. But there’s a fine line between wholesome humor and blandness, and Call Me Kat often falls on the wrong side of that line.
The show also seems to be reaching for a sense of nostalgia, both in its aesthetic and its tone. There’s something comforting about its old-school sitcom vibe, but nostalgia alone isn’t enough to carry a series. Without sharper writing or more compelling characters, the show risks feeling like a relic of the past rather than a fresh take on the genre.
A Strong Lead, but a Weak Ensemble
Mayim Bialik brings an undeniable charm to the role of Kat. She’s bubbly, self-deprecating, and fully committed to the character. Her performance is one of the show’s few consistent strengths, and she manages to make even the weakest jokes somewhat endearing.
But a sitcom is only as strong as its ensemble, and this is where Call Me Kat falters. The supporting characters often feel one-dimensional, existing more as props for Kat’s antics than as fully realized individuals. It’s a shame because there’s clear potential in the cast, but the writing doesn’t give them enough to work with.
For a show that aims to celebrate individuality, it’s ironic that so many of its characters feel interchangeable. From a Christian perspective, this lack of depth is particularly disappointing. Stories have the power to reveal truths about human nature and our relationship with God, but that requires characters who feel real, with struggles and triumphs we can relate to.
Room for Growth: Can Kat Find Her Stride?
Despite its flaws, Call Me Kat isn’t without hope. The show’s premise is solid, and with stronger writing and a willingness to take risks, it could grow into something worth watching. There’s potential in Kat’s journey to redefine success and happiness, and if the show can lean into that narrative, it might find a way to stand out.
For Christian viewers, Call Me Kat offers an opportunity to reflect on what it means to live authentically. Kat’s determination to embrace her quirks and forge her own path is admirable, even if the execution leaves something to be desired. But the show also serves as a reminder that authenticity isn’t just about being different; it’s about being true to who God created us to be.
Final Thoughts: A Work in Progress
Call Me Kat is a show that wants to be loved, but it’s still figuring out how to earn that love. It’s charming but clumsy, well-meaning but shallow. For all its potential, it feels like a rough draft of something better—a story waiting to be told with more depth, humor, and heart.
As Christians, we can appreciate the show’s clean humor and its emphasis on individuality, but we might also find ourselves longing for a narrative with more substance. Like Kat herself, the show is a work in progress, full of potential but not quite there yet.
Rating: 5/10
Good-hearted and occasionally charming, but weighed down by stale humor and underdeveloped characters. Watch it if you’re in the mood for something light, but don’t expect it to leave a lasting impression.
